Collection log - items shared between NPC's

[Rapsey]

For example: if I get a Draconic Visage from Frost Dragons, should it also count that drop for the Lava Dragons, King Black Dragon and Vorkath?

On OSRS the items are shared AFAIK, so getting a drop once completes it for all. At first I thought it was really weird to mark drops for NPC's you didn't get them from, but it's just another way of looking at it I guess. Then the collection log is more a way of asking: is there anything I can get from this NPC that I don't have yet?

We can go either way on this. It's whatever you guys prefer.

PS: Anyone who suggests togglescape will have to get each drop 10 times to get it marked.

EDIT: One very important thing to note:

The vast majority of these shared items are not actually NPC drops. They are shared between chests, easy/hard/elite treasure trails, mystery boxes etc. So although it would no longer give you an accurate representation of how many you got from each, it might be better to share them anyway because it'd be a royal pain to have to obtain all the items from all those possible sources.

[Nazuths]

I can't really think of any rare/unique item that is shared between bosses. But let's do it the OSRS way for @Respire1337

[Cancerstick]

Given the option, I would rather see the drops only count for the mob that dropped them.

Would be a little something more to work for if you wanted to actually work towards ‘completing’ the log.

[Rapsey]

I can't really think of any rare/unique item that is shared between bosses. But let's do it the OSRS way for @Respire1337

There's quite a few. First number is how many NPC's drop it. (Or other sources like chests, caskets etc)

Spoiler: show

10 - item: 11942 # Ecumenical key
6 - item: 5586 # Metal spade
4 - item: 7368 # Studded chaps (t)
4 - item: 7366 # Studded chaps (g)
4 - item: 7364 # Studded body (t)
4 - item: 7362 # Studded body (g)
4 - item: 7360 # Rune shield (h5)
4 - item: 7358 # Adamant shield (h5)
4 - item: 7350 # Black shield (h4)
4 - item: 20235 # Ancient blessing
4 - item: 20232 # War blessing
4 - item: 20229 # Honourable blessing
4 - item: 20226 # Peaceful blessing
4 - item: 20223 # Unholy blessing
4 - item: 20220 # Holy blessing
4 - item: 11822 # Godsword shard 3
4 - item: 11820 # Godsword shard 2
4 - item: 11818 # Godsword shard 1
4 - item: 11286 # Draconic visage
4 - item: 10976 # Long bone
3 - item: 6924 # Infinity bottoms
3 - item: 6922 # Infinity gloves
3 - item: 6920 # Infinity boots
3 - item: 6918 # Infinity hat
3 - item: 6916 # Infinity top
3 - item: 6889 # Mage's book
3 - item: 6794 # Choc-ice
3 - item: 6739 # Dragon axe
3 - item: 6729 # Dagannoth bones
3 - item: 42854 # Rune plateskirt (h5)
3 - item: 42852 # Rune platelegs (h5)
3 - item: 42850 # Rune platebody (h5)
3 - item: 42836 # Rune plateskirt (h4)
3 - item: 42834 # Rune platelegs (h4)
3 - item: 42832 # Rune platebody (h4)
3 - item: 42818 # Rune plateskirt (h3)
3 - item: 42816 # Rune platelegs (h3)
3 - item: 42814 # Rune platebody (h3)
3 - item: 42800 # Rune plateskirt (h2)
3 - item: 42798 # Rune platelegs (h2)
3 - item: 42796 # Rune platebody (h2)
3 - item: 42782 # Rune plateskirt (h1)
3 - item: 42780 # Rune platelegs (h1)
3 - item: 42778 # Rune platebody (h1)
3 - item: 41824 # Dragon claws
3 - item: 41820 # Hand cannon
3 - item: 41810 # Divine sigil
3 - item: 3480 # Guthix plateskirt
3 - item: 3479 # Saradomin plateskirt
3 - item: 3478 # Zamorak plateskirt
3 - item: 3477 # Rune plateskirt (t)
3 - item: 3476 # Rune plateskirt (g)
3 - item: 2675 # Guthix kiteshield
3 - item: 2673 # Guthix full helm
3 - item: 2671 # Guthix platelegs
3 - item: 2669 # Guthix platebody
3 - item: 2667 # Saradomin kiteshield
3 - item: 2665 # Saradomin full helm
3 - item: 2663 # Saradomin platelegs
3 - item: 2661 # Saradomin platebody
3 - item: 2659 # Zamorak kiteshield
3 - item: 2657 # Zamorak full helm
3 - item: 2655 # Zamorak platelegs
3 - item: 2653 # Zamorak platebody
3 - item: 2629 # Rune kiteshield (t)
3 - item: 2627 # Rune full helm (t)
3 - item: 2625 # Rune platelegs (t)
3 - item: 2623 # Rune platebody (t)
3 - item: 2621 # Rune kiteshield (g)
3 - item: 2619 # Rune full helm (g)
3 - item: 2617 # Rune platelegs (g)
3 - item: 2615 # Rune platebody (g)
3 - item: 19936 # Zamorak d'hide boots
3 - item: 19933 # Saradomin d'hide boots
3 - item: 19930 # Armadyl d'hide boots
3 - item: 19927 # Guthix d'hide boots
3 - item: 19924 # Bandos d'hide boots
3 - item: 12827 # Arcane sigil
3 - item: 12823 # Spectral sigil
3 - item: 12819 # Elysian sigil
3 - item: 12512 # Armadyl coif
3 - item: 12510 # Armadyl chaps
3 - item: 12508 # Armadyl dragonhide
3 - item: 12506 # Armadyl bracers
3 - item: 12504 # Bandos coif
3 - item: 12502 # Bandos chaps
3 - item: 12500 # Bandos dragonhide
3 - item: 12498 # Bandos bracers
3 - item: 12488 # Bandos kiteshield
3 - item: 12486 # Bandos full helm
3 - item: 12484 # Bandos plateskirt
3 - item: 12482 # Bandos platelegs
3 - item: 12480 # Bandos platebody
3 - item: 12478 # Armadyl kiteshield
3 - item: 12476 # Armadyl full helm
3 - item: 12474 # Armadyl plateskirt
3 - item: 12472 # Armadyl platelegs
3 - item: 12470 # Armadyl platebody
3 - item: 12275 # Bandos crozier
3 - item: 12273 # Bandos cloak
3 - item: 12271 # Bandos mitre
3 - item: 12269 # Bandos stole
3 - item: 12267 # Bandos robe legs
3 - item: 12265 # Bandos robe top
3 - item: 12263 # Armadyl crozier
3 - item: 12261 # Armadyl cloak
3 - item: 12259 # Armadyl mitre
3 - item: 12257 # Armadyl stole
3 - item: 12255 # Armadyl robe legs
3 - item: 12253 # Armadyl robe top
3 - item: 12199 # Ancient crozier
3 - item: 11995 # Chaos Elemental Jr.
3 - item: 11920 # Dragon pickaxe
3 - item: 11335 # Dragon full helm
3 - item: 10474 # Zamorak stole
3 - item: 10472 # Guthix stole
3 - item: 10470 # Saradomin stole
3 - item: 10468 # Zamorak robe legs
3 - item: 10466 # Guthix robe legs
3 - item: 10464 # Saradomin robe legs
3 - item: 10462 # Guthix robe top
3 - item: 10460 # Zamorak robe top
3 - item: 10458 # Saradomin robe top
3 - item: 10456 # Zamorak mitre
3 - item: 10454 # Guthix mitre
3 - item: 10452 # Saradomin mitre
3 - item: 10450 # Zamorak cloak
3 - item: 10448 # Guthix cloak
3 - item: 10446 # Saradomin cloak
3 - item: 10444 # Zamorak crozier
3 - item: 10442 # Guthix crozier
3 - item: 10440 # Saradomin crozier
3 - item: 10390 # Saradomin coif
3 - item: 10388 # Saradomin chaps
3 - item: 10386 # Saradomin dragonhide
3 - item: 10384 # Saradomin bracers
3 - item: 10382 # Guthix coif
3 - item: 10380 # Guthix chaps
3 - item: 10378 # Guthix dragonhide
3 - item: 10376 # Guthix bracers
3 - item: 10374 # Zamorak coif
3 - item: 10372 # Zamorak chaps
3 - item: 10370 # Zamorak dragonhide
3 - item: 10368 # Zamorak bracers
2 - item: 9006 # Fighting boots
2 - item: 9005 # Fancy boots
2 - item: 8788 # Magic stone
2 - item: 7396 # Blue wizard hat (t)
2 - item: 7394 # Blue wizard hat (g)
2 - item: 7392 # Blue wizard robe (t)
2 - item: 7390 # Blue wizard robe (g)
2 - item: 7388 # Blue wizard skirt (t)
2 - item: 7386 # Blue wizard skirt (g)
2 - item: 7239 # Rapid renewal scroll
2 - item: 7238 # Augury scroll
2 - item: 7236 # Rigour scroll
2 - item: 4502 # Bearhead
2 - item: 43040 # Baby WildyWyrm
2 - item: 43036 # Baby Corporeal Beast
2 - item: 42910 # Frost dragon mask
2 - item: 42908 # Black unicorn mask
2 - item: 42906 # White unicorn mask
2 - item: 42904 # Fox mask
2 - item: 42900 # Bat mask
2 - item: 42848 # Adamant plateskirt (h5)
2 - item: 42846 # Adamant platelegs (h5)
2 - item: 42844 # Adamant platebody (h5)
2 - item: 42842 # Black plateskirt (h5)
2 - item: 42840 # Black platelegs (h5)
2 - item: 42838 # Black platebody (h5)
2 - item: 42830 # Adamant plateskirt (h4)
2 - item: 42828 # Adamant platelegs (h4)
2 - item: 42826 # Adamant platebody (h4)
2 - item: 42824 # Black plateskirt (h4)
2 - item: 42822 # Black platelegs (h4)
2 - item: 42820 # Black platebody (h4)
2 - item: 42812 # Adamant plateskirt (h3)
2 - item: 42810 # Adamant platelegs (h3)
2 - item: 42808 # Adamant platebody (h3)
2 - item: 42806 # Black plateskirt (h3)
2 - item: 42804 # Black platelegs (h3)
2 - item: 42802 # Black platebody (h3)
2 - item: 42794 # Adamant plateskirt (h2)
2 - item: 42792 # Adamant platelegs (h2)
2 - item: 42790 # Adamant platebody (h2)
2 - item: 42788 # Black plateskirt (h2)
2 - item: 42786 # Black platelegs (h2)
2 - item: 42784 # Black platebody (h2)
2 - item: 42776 # Adamant plateskirt (h1)
2 - item: 42774 # Adamant platelegs (h1)
2 - item: 42772 # Adamant platebody (h1)
2 - item: 42770 # Black plateskirt (h1)
2 - item: 42768 # Black platelegs (h1)
2 - item: 42766 # Black platebody (h1)
2 - item: 42764 # Infinity bottoms (earth)
2 - item: 42762 # Infinity hat (earth)
2 - item: 42760 # Infinity top (earth)
2 - item: 42758 # Infinity bottoms (fire)
2 - item: 42756 # Infinity hat (fire)
2 - item: 42754 # Infinity top (fire)
2 - item: 42752 # Infinity bottoms (water)
2 - item: 42750 # Infinity hat (water)
2 - item: 42748 # Infinity top (water)
2 - item: 42746 # Infinity bottoms (air)
2 - item: 42744 # Infinity hat (air)
2 - item: 42742 # Infinity top (air)
2 - item: 41838 # Dagon'hai robes
2 - item: 41836 # Dagon'hai hat
2 - item: 41834 # Dagon'hai robe top
2 - item: 41826 # Staff of light
2 - item: 41804 # Donator status
2 - item: 41750 # Third age druidic robe
2 - item: 41748 # Third age druidic robe top
2 - item: 41746 # Third age druidic wreath
2 - item: 41744 # Third age druidic cloak
2 - item: 41742 # Third age druidic staff
2 - item: 4084 # Sled
2 - item: 3475 # Adamant plateskirt (g)
2 - item: 3474 # Adamant plateskirt (t)
2 - item: 3473 # Black plateskirt (g)
2 - item: 3472 # Black plateskirt (t)
2 - item: 3140 # Dragon chainbody
2 - item: 2613 # Adamant full helm (g)
2 - item: 2611 # Adamant kiteshield (g)
2 - item: 2609 # Adamant platelegs (g)
2 - item: 2607 # Adamant platebody (g)
2 - item: 2605 # Adamant full helm (t)
2 - item: 2603 # Adamant kiteshield (t)
2 - item: 2601 # Adamant platelegs (t)
2 - item: 2599 # Adamant platebody (t)
2 - item: 2597 # Black kiteshield (g)
2 - item: 2595 # Black full helm (g)
2 - item: 2593 # Black platelegs (g)
2 - item: 2591 # Black platebody (g)
2 - item: 2587 # Black full helm (t)
2 - item: 2585 # Black platelegs (t)
2 - item: 2583 # Black platebody (t)
2 - item: 2579 # Wizard boots
2 - item: 22746 # Ikkle hydra
2 - item: 22473 # Lil' zik
2 - item: 21992 # Vorki
2 - item: 21880 # Wrath rune
2 - item: 21273 # Skotos
2 - item: 20693 # Phoenix
2 - item: 20667 # Rift guardian
2 - item: 20663 # Rocky
2 - item: 20661 # Tangleroot
2 - item: 20659 # Giant_squirrel
2 - item: 19921 # Ancient d'hide boots
2 - item: 19685 # Dark totem
2 - item: 19683 # Dark totem top
2 - item: 19681 # Dark totem middle
2 - item: 19679 # Dark totem base
2 - item: 19677 # Ancient shard
2 - item: 13324 # Baby chinchompa
2 - item: 13322 # Beaver
2 - item: 13321 # Rock golem
2 - item: 13320 # Heron
2 - item: 13262 # Abyssal orphan
2 - item: 13247 # Hellpuppy
2 - item: 13225 # TzRek-Jad
2 - item: 13181 # Scorpia's offspring
2 - item: 13178 # Callisto cub
2 - item: 13177 # Venenatis Jr.
2 - item: 13071 # Chompy Chick
2 - item: 12954 # Dragon defender
2 - item: 12921 # Pet snakeling
2 - item: 12833 # Holy elixir
2 - item: 12829 # Spirit shield
2 - item: 12655 # Baby Kraken
2 - item: 12653 # Prince black dragon
2 - item: 12652 # K'ril Tsutsaroth Jr.
2 - item: 12651 # Zilyana Jr.
2 - item: 12650 # Graardor Jr.
2 - item: 12649 # Kree'Arra Jr.
2 - item: 12648 # Baby Smoke Devil
2 - item: 12647 # Kalphite princess
2 - item: 12646 # Baby mole
2 - item: 12645 # Dagannoth Rex Jr.
2 - item: 12644 # Dagannoth Prime Jr.
2 - item: 12643 # Dagannoth Supreme Jr.
2 - item: 12524 # Black dragon mask
2 - item: 12522 # Red dragon mask
2 - item: 12520 # Blue dragon mask
2 - item: 12518 # Green dragon mask
2 - item: 12496 # Ancient coif
2 - item: 12494 # Ancient chaps
2 - item: 12492 # Ancient dragonhide
2 - item: 12490 # Ancient bracers
2 - item: 12468 # Ancient kiteshield
2 - item: 12466 # Ancient full helm
2 - item: 12464 # Ancient plateskirt
2 - item: 12462 # Ancient platelegs
2 - item: 12460 # Ancient platebody
2 - item: 12428 # Penguin mask
2 - item: 12369 # Mithril dragon mask
2 - item: 12367 # Steel dragon mask
2 - item: 12365 # Iron dragon mask
2 - item: 12363 # Bronze dragon mask
2 - item: 12203 # Ancient mitre
2 - item: 12201 # Ancient stole
2 - item: 12197 # Ancient cloak
2 - item: 12195 # Ancient robe legs
2 - item: 12193 # Ancient robe top
2 - item: 11838 # Saradomin sword
2 - item: 11808 # Zamorak godsword
2 - item: 11806 # Saradomin godsword
2 - item: 11804 # Bandos godsword
2 - item: 11802 # Armadyl godsword
2 - item: 11022 # Chicken legs
2 - item: 11021 # Chicken head
2 - item: 11020 # Chicken wings
2 - item: 11019 # Chicken feet
2 - item: 1057 # Red halloween mask
2 - item: 1055 # Blue halloween mask
2 - item: 1053 # Green halloween mask
2 - item: 1050 # Santa hat
2 - item: 1048 # White partyhat
2 - item: 1046 # Purple partyhat
2 - item: 1044 # Green partyhat
2 - item: 1042 # Blue partyhat
2 - item: 1040 # Yellow partyhat
2 - item: 1038 # Red partyhat
2 - item: 1025 # Right eye patch

[Respire1337]

I want togglescape, thanks Rapsey!

The only 2 unique drops from bosses that I know of that are shared between multiple mobs are the smouldering stone ( Cerberus and hellhounds ) and the abyssal dagger ( Abyssal Sire and abyssal demons ) @Nazuths

Being required to obtain items that are dropped by a specific mob would be better and much more challenging. So, no, I say no to shared drops between mods (for certain uniques), but yes to shared drops for common items ( like draconic visages).

Also @Rapsey, why are there 2 sources for certain pets? Clue items should be shared.

[Rapsey]

Given the option, I would rather see the drops only count for the mob that dropped them.

Would be a little something more to work for if you wanted to actually work towards ‘completing’ the log.

It also has the benefit of properly tracking your drops. I.e. the page tells you you have 1000 kills on this boss and 10 drops of a particular item, then you know you actually got 10 from this boss and not maybe 1 from this boss and 9 from others.

I want togglescape, thanks Rapsey!

Not an option, sorry.

Being required to obtain items that are dropped by a specific mob would be better and much more challenging. So, no, I say no to shared drops between mods (for certain uniques), but yes to shared drops for common items ( like draconic visages).

Also not an option. It's either for all drops or for none. This is a fundamental decision in the way things are stored and how uniqueness is determined so we can't do it both ways.

Also @Rapsey, why are there 2 sources for certain pets? Clue items should be shared.

Those are actually wrongly listed here. They are not obtained from different sources, they just appear on multiple tabs (e.g. Pet Snakeling is on the Zulrah tab but also on the All Pets tab). But that's possible because they are still counted as a unique drop for Zulrah, it just gets displayed in more than one place. So that's not quite the same as registering some drops uniquely and others shared.


One very important thing to note:

The vast majority of these shared items are not actually NPC drops. They are shared between chests, easy/hard/elite treasure trails, mystery boxes etc. So although it would no longer give you an accurate representation of how many you got from each, it might be better to share them anyway because it'd be a royal pain to have to obtain all the items from all those possible sources.

[Respire1337]

Given the option, I would rather see the drops only count for the mob that dropped them.

Would be a little something more to work for if you wanted to actually work towards ‘completing’ the log.

It also has the benefit of properly tracking your drops. I.e. the page tells you you have 1000 kills on this boss and 10 drops of a particular item, then you know you actually got 10 from this boss and not maybe 1 from this boss and 9 from others.

I want togglescape, thanks Rapsey!

Not an option, sorry.

Being required to obtain items that are dropped by a specific mob would be better and much more challenging. So, no, I say no to shared drops between mods (for certain uniques), but yes to shared drops for common items ( like draconic visages).

Also not an option. It's either for all drops or for none. This is a fundamental decision in the way things are stored and how uniqueness is determined so we can't do it both ways.

Also @Rapsey, why are there 2 sources for certain pets? Clue items should be shared.

Those are actually wrongly listed here. They are not obtained from different sources, they just appear on multiple tabs (e.g. Pet Snakeling is on the Zulrah tab but also on the All Pets tab). But that's possible because they are still counted as a unique drop for Zulrah, it just gets displayed in more than one place. So that's not quite the same as registering some drops uniquely and others shared.


One very important thing to note:

The vast majority of these shared items are not actually NPC drops. They are shared between chests, easy/hard/elite treasure trails, mystery boxes etc. So although it would no longer give you an accurate representation of how many you got from each, it might be better to share them anyway because it'd be a royal pain to have to obtain all the items from all those possible sources.

Oh shit, if that's the case, then I'd say it's better to have them shared, exactly like OSRS does.

[Rapsey]

Also not an option. It's either for all drops or for none. This is a fundamental decision in the way things are stored and how uniqueness is determined so we can't do it both ways.

Okay I'm gonna backpedal on that one. It is doable to do both, e.g. have clue items be shared but monster drops be unique. But I am personally against mixing it up within these different categories (e.g. some monster drops are shared but others are not). That would just be hella confusing and also be a mess to code.

[Raj]

I'd like to be able to use my collection log to log what I got from each boss, personally. If I haven't killed Vorkath it doesn't make sense to have drops filled in at Vorkath I think. The only exception to this should be for clues, which I think should just be one giant tab called 'clues' and not split into difficulties, for the sake of not having to implement it both ways

[Respire1337]

I'd like to be able to use my collection log to log what I got from each boss, personally. If I haven't killed Vorkath it doesn't make sense to have drops filled in at Vorkath I think. The only exception to this should be for clues, which I think should just be one giant tab called 'clues' and not split into difficulties, for the sake of not having to implement it both ways

Okay, so pretty much this. Not shared for pvm, shared for clues. Seems fine?